Best Pizza in connecticut : 11 Must-Visit Pizzerias

by Laura C. Jones

Connecticut, with its rich history of artisanal pizza-making, has become a focal point for pizza enthusiasts. 

From its iconic thin crusts to the perfectly charred toppings, the Constitution State’s pizza landscape is varied, nostalgic, and mouth-wateringly delicious.

 Let’s dive into 11 of Connecticut’s finest pizzerias that should be on every pizza lover’s bucket list.

1. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana – New Haven  

Regarded as one of the top spots to order a pie in Connecticut, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana first opened its doors in 1925. 

While it has branched out to West Hartford, Fairfield, Danbury, and Manchester, the New Haven outlet remains the original dining gem.

The variety of pizzas offered here is extensive, from classic tomato pies to Margherita, Mozzarella with Italian sausage, Mozzarella with pepperoni, and the famed white clam pizza. 

This establishment embodies the authentic New Haven pizza spirit.

Location: 157 Wooster St, New Haven, CT

2. Sally’s Apizza – New Haven  

Established in the 1930s, Sally’s Apizza has earned a reputation for its splendid coal-fired pies. It has witnessed many eras, and though there are several outlets, the one in New Haven stands iconic.

From their delectable Margherita to the Mozzarella with Italian sausage, each pizza tells a story. The standout, however, is their coal-charred crust, representing true New Haven pizza culture.

Sally’s is more than a pizzeria; it’s a piece of New Haven’s rich pizza tapestry.

Location: 237 Wooster St, New Haven, CT

3. Modern Apizza – New Haven  

New Haven’s Modern Apizza stands as a beacon of innovation amidst traditional pizza giants. Since its inception in 1934, it has consistently pushed boundaries while honoring its roots.

Their Italian Bomb pizza is a sensation, layering multiple toppings for an explosive flavor profile. At Modern Apizza, it’s not just about revisiting tradition, but about envisioning the future of pizza.

Location: 874 State St, New Haven, CT

4. Colony Grill – Stamford  

Colony Grill, dating back to its early days in Stamford, is renowned for its unique thin-crust pizzas. This Stamford treasure has seen it all.

What sets them apart? Their spicy hot oil drizzled pizzas. From the first bite to the last, it’s a flavorful experience that embodies the spirit of Stamford’s pizza scene.

Location: 172 Myrtle Ave, Stamford, CT

5. Zuppardi’s Apizza – West Haven  

West Haven’s pride, Zuppardi’s Apizza, is a classic tale of passion meeting craftsmanship. This family-run pizzeria, operating since the 1930s, is a nexus of community and flavor.

The Fresh Clam pie, with its succulent clams and seasoned perfection, has patrons returning time and again. Zuppardi’s is not just a pizzeria; it’s a West Haven institution.

Location: 179 Union Ave, West Haven, CT

6. BAR – New Haven  

A relative newcomer compared to some historic joints, BAR in New Haven rapidly climbed the pizza charts. While it flourishes in the heart of pizza land, it has managed to carve a unique identity.

Famous for their Mashed Potato pizza, each pie is a tantalizing fusion of traditional and contemporary. Beyond just pizzas, BAR exemplifies the evolving spirit of New Haven’s culinary scene.

Location: 254 Crown St, New Haven, CT

7. Roseland Apizza – Derby  

A legend in its own right, Roseland Apizza has been serving the Derby community since the 1930s. This establishment is an embodiment of classic pizza nostalgia.

Their Shrimp Casino pizza is something of local lore. A visit to Roseland is like taking a step back in time, experiencing Derby’s rich pizza heritage firsthand.

Location: 350 Hawthorne Ave, Derby, CT

8. Alforno Trattoria – Old Saybrook  

Located in the coastal town of Old Saybrook, Alforno Trattoria blends seaside charm with mouth-watering pizzas. With its distinct ambiance, it’s more than just a pizzeria.

Their Clams Casino pie, with its ocean-fresh clams, is a crowd favorite. Alforno Trattoria celebrates both Old Saybrook’s coastal roots and its profound love for pizza.

Location: 1654 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT

9. Pepe’s Pizza – Danbury  

Though it shares a lineage with the famed Frank Pepe’s of New Haven, Pepe’s Pizza in Danbury offers its own flair. It captures the essence of both its rich heritage and Danbury’s vibrant community.

Signature pies like the Margherita maintain the family tradition, while unique offerings cater to Danbury’s diverse clientele. Each slice is a testament to timeless pizza craftsmanship.

Location: 59 Federal Rd, Danbury, CT

10. Mystic Pizza – Mystic  

Gaining fame from the namesake movie, Mystic Pizza in the picturesque town of Mystic is more than just a movie landmark. It’s a place where art meets culinary expertise.

While the Seafood Delight is a nod to Mystic’s maritime culture, every pizza on the menu tells a story. It’s not just about food; it’s about capturing the essence of Mystic in every bite.

Location: 56 W Main St, Mystic, CT

11. Nana’s Bakery & Pizza – Mystic  

While Mystic is known for its sea-bound allure, Nana’s Bakery & Pizza is a landlubber’s delight. Infusing traditional pizza with bakery-inspired twists, it’s a fresh take in a historic town.

Their Meat Lovers pizza, with its assortment of cured meats, pays homage to classic Italian traditions. Nana’s is where the warmth of a bakery meets the zest of a pizzeria.

Location: 32 Water St, Mystic, CT


Connecticut’s pizzerias are not just eateries; they are establishments that have encapsulated decades of history, tradition, and culinary excellence. 

Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, exploring this pizza landscape offers not only a treat for the palate but also a journey through the state’s rich pizza heritage. 

So, the next time you’re in Connecticut, make sure you tick off some of these legendary spots from your list. After all, a slice of Connecticut’s pizza is a slice of its history.

Related Posts