Finance Law Uncategorized

What's next for Mickelson if insider trading probe fails to make the green?

A possible leak in an insider trading probe targeting Phil Mickelson could give regulators little chance at a case and Mickelson the right to sue.

Golf: The Masters-Second Round
(Jack Gruber-USA TODAY Sports)

News broke last week that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) are investigating three high profile names — Carl Icahn, Phil Mickelson, and sports gambler Billy Walters — over possible acts of insider trading.

To date, no allegations of wrongdoing have been brought forth and most securities lawyers agree that it’s a weak case.

It’s still unclear what evidence the FBI and SEC have on the three gentlemen that could amount to an actual insider trading charge, but regulators have hurt their chance at building a stronger case through wiretapping and covert cooperation with the investigation becoming public.

Golf: The Masters-Par 3 Contest
(Jack Gruber-USA TODAY Sports)

INSIDER TRADING DIFFICULT TO PROVE

Insider trading cases have historically carried a high burden of proof.

Did an “insider” provide material, non-public information to another party? Did this individual know it was material, non-public information at the time? Who qualifies as an “insider”? Did anyone personally benefit from the trade, and was a fiduciary duty of trust or confidence broken in the process?

Icahn — a prominent activist investor known for taking large stakes in companies — was not an insider of bleach maker Clorox, the company upon which trades are being questioned. Nor would Icahn’s desire to acquire a large stake in a company qualify as material, non-public information by definition.

It’s an extremely weak case to begin with and now, with the cat out of the bag on the investigation, regulators have no firm tee to swing on.

Golf: The Masters-Final Round
(Jack Gruber-USA TODAY Sports)

SPONSORS STANDING BEHIND MICKELSON

Mickelson appears to be fully backed by major endorsers Callaway and KPMG LLP who publicly stood behind their golfer when the investigation made news. Sponsors should continue their support given no evidence of wrongdoing or malfeasance by Mickelson.

Now, with the investigation nearly undone by the possible leak, Mickelson and his public relations team must repair the good image he’s built over his career.

Should the insider trading probe end with a whimper and not a bang, Mickelson may take legal action against the SEC for tarnishing his public image which, no matter how successful he is at clearing his name, will inextricably become associated with this investigation.

0 comments on “What's next for Mickelson if insider trading probe fails to make the green?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: